Full Review: Phoenix – Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix

Phoenix seems to have come onto the US stage rather quickly and thus you may be unsure of who exactly they are. Briefly summed up this band is all about finding the pop/rock/dance groove and exploiting it to the point that the songs follow you around. “Lisztomania” may have you convinced that you can’t live without this band keeping you company, but what about the rest of the record?
Musically, Phoenix brings mostly mid-paced euro dance rock to the table which has been pumped full of, what can only be described as, high levels of preservatives keeping them fresher longer than similar offerings from other bands. After your first listen to any of the songs it seems like the drums are the driving force behind the band but the beauty or sneakiness is that the vocals are actually what gives this band the dance-ability they carry. While I’m not suggesting the drums don’t have a major role in the sound I’m just suggesting that when you hear “…Going hey hey hey hey hey hey hey” from “1901″ that that’s the biggest pull for the song. Oddly though when watching the music video or the band performing live on TV, vocalist Thomas Mars comes off rather ridged, at least more so than the fluid figure which the songs suggest.
Leading off with hands down the strongest track, “Lisztomania” sets expectations very high for the rest of the album and I wouldn’t say it doesn’t live up but it just goes down a path that was not predictable by that lead single. “1901″ followed by “Fences” begins easing out of the dance party into a slightly slower groove, slightly being the key word. One of the worst things about this album is the order that the songs are presented in. I know this may sound absolutely absurd but the order of the songs really does matter to an albums overall presentation which is why having parts 1 and 2 of “Love Like A Sunset” so early in the order was a huge mistake. There needed to be a few more tracks like “Rome” or “Girlfriend” before the epic 5 and a half minute instrumental, which is, Part 1. Constantly building only to deflate and build back up “Love Like A Sunset” finally concludes with the lyrics “Oh where it starts it ends, love like a sunset” and gives a perfect resolution to the nearly 8 minutes.
On the other side of the album dividing instrumental resides tracks which take the approach of less is more. “Lasso”, whether on purpose or not, is able to recreate some of the immediate draw that “Lisztomania” had but does so in a more subtle way. Lyrically, the record leaves a lot to be desired. Most songs fall into the category of being to ambiguous to mean to much anyone except for random cases I suppose, but in the end they [the words] merely prop up the melody.
Not world changing by any means, ‘Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix’ doesn’t go for broke, it goes for consistency and succeeds. Hardly a song or rather a time which you can’t tap your fingers on the desk while listening, this album is for those looking for an fun escape.








May 6th, 2009 at 7:49 pm
I agree mostly with your review. This album is awesome. I got an early release of it and I can’t stop listening to it. I’ve liked Phoenix for a while now and will be seeing them live in June. And I thought they weren’t going to be able to top their last album… should have known better.
May 7th, 2009 at 10:44 pm
I agree with the your take on the odd placement of “Love Like a Sunset”…but luckily, the other 8 tracks on the album are solid and more than make up for it(especially the lineup of “Rome”, “Countdown” and “Girlfriend”). To me, they are what make Phoenix’s sound so unique…and will make great songs for the summer.
My favorite Phoenix album is “Alphabetical”, mainly because it has only a few songs could occasionally skip over, but Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix doesn’t have one song I can skip over…which to me, makes a 5of5 album.
Anyway, just my opinion. I appreciate your reviews! Thank you!
May 8th, 2009 at 7:09 am
Thanks
May 9th, 2009 at 3:20 am
I think your review is fair, but on the whole, a bit cynical. I disagree with your take on Mars’ voice. Every singer sounds better in the studio–that’s the point, but I don’t think Mars’ live performances are a far cry from his studio sound, or at least the best aspects of his voice are still there. I just wanted to point this out because I’ve always held this opinion and was surprised that you thought the opposite.
May 9th, 2009 at 11:38 am
I was not talking about vocal quality but rather stage presence. I actually think the live stuff sounds good.
May 11th, 2009 at 2:00 am
Far too harsh. This album is the best pop/rock album since the early Shins stuff.
Also, I’m not sure what you mean by “Lyrically there is a lot to be desired from this album” – do you mean ‘leaves a lot to be desired’?
May 11th, 2009 at 8:04 am
@avro I think the album sells itself and there is very little convincing that needs to be done and so for the sake of commenting on/reviewing it’s worth pointing out some of the flaws. I still think the album is worth buying.
May 15th, 2009 at 9:51 am
Um, the lyrics to “Lisztomania” are not nonsensical, they’re about the pianist Franz Liszt and the way he influenced music…
The review is quite good, I just don’t think the 3/5 really fit, after reading the review a 4/5 would fit better.
For me this album is a 4/5, best album I’ve heard this year.